skip to main content

Judge allows DNA evidence in Massereene trial

Patrick Azimkar and Mark Quinsey were shot dead in March 2009
Patrick Azimkar and Mark Quinsey were shot dead in March 2009

The judge in the Massereene murder trial has ruled that controversial DNA evidence is admissible despite a challenge by the defence.

Colin Duffy, 44, and Brian Shivers, 46, deny murdering Sappers Patrick Azimkar and Mark Quinsey.

The soldiers were killed as they collected a delivery of pizza in March 2009.

It is the first time evidence based on a new US DNA test has been admitted in a UK or Irish court.

Dr Mark Perlin, an expert witness from the US, used a computer-based statistical method to assess DNA taken from items in the alleged getaway car, found partially burnt out a few kilometres from the shootings.

He alleged that DNA on a seatbelt buckle was 5.91 trillion times more likely to have come from Mr Duffy than anyone else.

Dr Perlin said samples on a mobile phone were six billion times more likely to have come from Mr Shivers than any other person.

Mr Justice Anthony Hart said: "I am satisfied that the stage has now been reached in the case of this system where it can be regarded as being reliable and acceptable and I am satisfied that Dr (Mark) Perlin has given his evidence in a credible and reliable fashion.

"In the light of this conclusion, I can see no basis under which I could possibly exercise my discretion to exclude this evidence and I therefore admit it in evidence."