skip to main content

UK doctors say Johnson 'irresponsible' to ease lockdown

The BMA council chair said it was 'frankly perilous' to lift restrictions on 19 July
The BMA council chair said it was 'frankly perilous' to lift restrictions on 19 July

The British Medical Association has condemned UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson's "irresponsible" decision to press ahead with lockdown lifting in England despite Covid-19 infections continuing to surge.

The BMA warned of "potentially devastating consequences" after the prime minister confirmed yesterday that most mandatory restrictions will end next week.

At a Downing Street news conference, Mr Johnson acknowledged the pandemic "is not over" and appealed to people to proceed with caution.

At the same time, he said postponing the easing of restrictions into the autumn would risk reopening at a time when schools are back from their summer holidays and people are spending more time indoors as the weather turns cold.

However, Dr Chaand Nagpaul, the BMA council chair, said that by going ahead on 19 July, the British government was reneging on its promise to be led by the data and the impact on the NHS.

He said scrapping restrictions while a significant proportion of the population was still not fully vaccinated, would allow the virus to "retighten its grip", driving up infections and hospitalisations and putting more lives at risk.

"It's irresponsible - and frankly perilous - that the government has decided to press ahead with plans to lift the remaining Covid-19 restrictions on 19 July," he said.

"The BMA has repeatedly warned of the rapidly rising infection rate and the crippling impact that Covid-related hospitalisations continue to have on the NHS, not only pushing staff to the brink of collapse but also driving up already lengthy waiting times for elective care.

"The prime minister repeatedly emphasised the importance of a slow and cautious approach, but in reality the government is throwing caution to the wind by scrapping all regulations in one fell swoop - with potentially devastating consequences."

The latest daily official figures showed cases continue to surge with a further 34,471 laboratory-confirmed infections in the UK as of 9am on Monday.

Under current modelling, the peak of the wave is not expected before mid-August, when there could be 1,000 to 2,000 hospital admissions per day, with deaths expected to reach between 100 and 200 per day.

Professor Adam Finn, a member of the British government's Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI), said there was "considerable uncertainty" as to how the disease would play out in the coming weeks.

"I sympathise with the political message that this can't go on forever but on the other hand we really don't want to get to a situation where things get so bad that we have to reimpose restrictions and it's a very delicate balancing act to get that right," he said.

"The more you let the genie out of the bottle the harder it is to put it back in, though there is a large amount of uncertainty."

However Paul Hunter, professor in medicine at the University of East Anglia, said there was "ample evidence" vaccines were dramatically reducing the risk of death and incidence of severe disease.

"Although hospitalisation rates are rising rapidly at present, we can expect these to have slowed substantially within the next week or two," he said

"That does not mean that relaxing restrictions has no risk. But I would argue leaving Step 4 (lockdown lifting) till the autumn carries a far greater risk."

Professor Calum Semple, a member of the UK Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies, said the "winter bump" will be a mixture of Covid and all the other "respiratory viruses that we didn't experience in the last year or so".

Speaking in a personal capacity, he told BBC Breakfast: "That's why I'm saying, 'we're going to have a miserable winter, I'm sorry, we're going to have a rough winter'."

Asked whether restrictions would come back, he said: "Possibly, and it may just be about reinforcing some common sense. It may be bringing back some mask-wearing in certain environments, but I don't foresee the lockdowns or the school suspensions that we've seen."

He also said there were some older people in hospital where the vaccine "just can't help" them "because they're older, and the immune system doesn't protect them".

Prof Semple said he felt the biggest unlocking was May 17, later saying it was "quite realistic" that there could be up to 2,000 hospital admissions per day.

He added: "My big message to people now is 'sure we've weakened the link between community cases and hospital cases, but that link is not broken and it's the people that are not vaccinated that are still coming to harm'."

The British government's decision means from next Monday social distancing rules will end and the wearing face masks will no longer be compulsory, although venues such as nightclubs are being urged to require "Covid certification" as a condition of entry.