skip to main content

Nicola Sturgeon survives no-confidence vote

The parliamentary committee was investigating what Nicola Sturgeon knew and when about the allegations against Alex Salmond
The parliamentary committee was investigating what Nicola Sturgeon knew and when about the allegations against Alex Salmond

Scotland's First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has survived a no-confidence vote in parliament and has vowed not to give in to "bully" tactics as she readies for a new drive to split the nation from the UK.

The motion brought by Scotland's opposition Conservatives was rejected by 65-31 votes with 27 abstentions.

The vote came after a Scottish parliamentary committee investigating a sexual harassment scandal involving Ms Sturgeon's predecessor, Alex Salmond, found that it had been misled by testimony from the first minister.

But the panel deferred to another probe by a senior independent lawyer who reported yesterday that Ms Sturgeon did not breach the ministerial code, effectively clearing the way for her to survive the no-confidence vote and lead her party into elections in May.

The row involving the two biggest names in the independence movement has dominated Scottish politics in recent years, with indications it has undermined popular support for Scotland to go its own way.

But Nicola Sturgeon's Scottish National Party (SNP) is hoping that with the investigations and parliamentary manoeuvres over, a strong showing in May will bolster its case for a second referendum on independence.

"If you think you can bully me out of office, you are mistaken," she told politicians ahead of the vote. "If you want to remove me as first minister, do it in an election.

"It is the confidence of the people of Scotland that matters most, and the confidence of the people is what I will seek to demonstrate and seek to win in the weeks that lie ahead."

After she was cleared in the independent probe, the SNP submitted legislation seeking to hold a new independence plebiscite by the end of 2023.

A previous vote in 2014 saw Scottish people opt to remain part of the union, and UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has repeatedly refused to allow a second referendum.

But the SNP argues that the UK's Brexit departure from the European Union, which most Scottish people opposed, has dramatically changed the political calculus.

If a majority in the Scottish Parliament supports another referendum after the May elections, there will be "no democratic justification whatsoever" for Mr Johnson to block it, SNP Constitution Secretary Michael Russell said.

Alex Salmond, who was first minister from 2007 to 2014, was cleared of all charges at a criminal trial last year, and says the accusations were politically motivated by his successor's team.

He accused Ms Sturgeon, his former friend and protegee, of a failure of leadership, charging that she breached the ministerial code governing behaviour and conduct.

Before the criminal trial, a civil court found the government probe into the complaints was unlawful and "tainted by apparent bias".

Mr Salmond, 66, was awarded more than £500,000 in legal costs.

While senior lawyer James Hamilton cleared Ms Sturgeon yesterday, the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints committee ruled separately that there was a "fundamental contradiction in the evidence" she gave.

It was investigating what she knew and when about the allegations against Mr Salmond, her government's handling of the complaints, and whether she offered to intervene on his behalf.

The SNP say the committee's findings were stacked against her by an opposition majority on the panel.