skip to main content

Daughter of UHL patient says he 'died with no dignity'

Anne Marie Abbott with her father Martin Abbott
Anne Marie Abbott with her father Martin Abbott

The daughter of a man who may have been dead for over an hour at University Hospital Limerick (UHL) before being found on the floor by staff has said she does not know if she will ever get over him dying "with no dignity".

An inquest into the death of Martin Abbott, 65, from Shannon, Co Clare heard he had died after falling from a trolley in the busy emergency department in December 2019.

A verdict of death by medical misadventure was recorded at the inquest.

"My father wasn't close to death," said Anne Marie Abbott, Mr Abbott's daughter. "But for him to have to die with no dignity is something that I don't know if I'll ever get over."

Speaking on RTÉ’s Drivetime, she described her father as "a very strong man, an absolute gentleman in every sense of the word" and said that he and her mother were looking forward to "travelling the world" after retirement.

Martin Abbott died in December 2019 and may have been on the floor in UHL for an hour before being found by staff

Ms Abbott said that she had raised concerns about her father's condition with hospital staff on the evening that he died.

"I felt his breathing was a bit laboured and I wanted something to be done. I was met with a bit of rudeness and they told me that it was nothing to do with them that he was under the care of the medic team... I was told that the doctor would be down within the hour to see dad.

"It was there at 6am and we got a phone call from my mother just stating that the guards were at the door, that UL Hospital was trying to contact us."

She said that the family went straight to the hospital and were told in a phone call that Mr Abbott had "a turn".

"The nurse in charge and the registrar on call told us he was dead, that he was found in a collapsed state by the sink and they suspected it was a heart attack. That was all the information that they gave us.

"I couldn't believe what I was hearing," she said.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences


Ms Abbott said that she heard about an investigation into her father’s death through local media and the family were not contacted about it first.

"They (UHL) did apologise for not contacting us, but I do feel that the communication should have been instant."

She said there was a need for reviews and examinations of how hospitals "do things and how they communicate".

"Communication with families and also with other medical professionals, it's breaking down everywhere. This is not just within UL Hospital Group, it's nationwide."

Ms Abbott said that her family still have a lot of unanswered questions but that "with the help of UL Hospital Group, hopefully, hopefully, I’ll get those" and that she would not wish what her family has gone through on anybody.

Anne Marie said she was going to 'work tirelessly' for her father

"It could all be prevented if they look and see how they're doing things. Accidents do happen, but it's how they manage these accidents and these tragedies and being honest and trustworthy, instead of prolonging heartache and grief for families.

Her father would always stand up for himself and others, Ms Abbott said, and that she was not standing up for him.

"I will work tirelessly to try and help this and fix this myself. But it's down to them at the end of the day," she said.

Yesterday's inquest heard from legal counsel for UHL, who said the hospital was taking steps to resolve issues raised and repeated apologies for deficits in care to Mr Abbots widow and daughter.

In a separate statement, UL Hospitals Group said it wishes to express its sincere sympathy to the family on their loss, adding that in this case, standards in relation to patient safety fell short of what was expected.

"We strive to uphold the highest standards of patient care and safety, and it's clear in this case, these standards fell short of what was expected," it said.

It added: "We apologise for the deficiencies and shortcomings in Mr Abbott’s care and for the distress and trauma this has caused his family."