skip to main content

Robinson accuses Israel of 'nonsense', 'malicious lying'

Former President Mary Robinson condemned as 'unconscionable' Israel's blocking aid deliveries to Gaza
Former President Mary Robinson condemned as 'unconscionable' Israel's blocking aid deliveries to Gaza

Former President Mary Robinson has condemned what she called "ridiculous", "nonsense" and "malicious lying" regarding Israeli claims that it is ready to distribute aid into Gaza.

Mrs Robinson said that Israeli claims that UN agencies are not working quickly enough to distribute aid are "all ridiculous".

"We saw the most there was incredible collaboration between the Egyptian Red Crescent... and the UN," she said, after a visit to Egypt and the Rafah crossing alongside former New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark.

Following the visit, Mrs Robinson said that targeted sanctions should be imposed on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and all members of his security cabinet.

Speaking on RTÉ's News at One, Mrs Robinson - who is a member of the NGO the Elders - said that there are "piles of vital materials that have been rejected, sent back. Tents, wheelchairs, crutches".

She saw two lorries coming back with food parcels and one driver told her that he had been rejected twice in 24 hours for very minor reasons, such as the load being "too high".

"I mean, for goodness sake," Mrs Robinson said, calling it "unconscionable".

"We need to prevent and to punish, not to allow genocide."

Israel has denied responsibility for hunger spreading in Gaza, accusing Hamas militants of stealing aid shipments, which Hamas denies.

However, in response to a rising international uproar, Israel late last month announced steps to let more aid into the enclave, including pausing fighting for part of the day in some areas and announcing protected routes for aid convoys.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences


'I don't know how many will die before September'

She praised "the effort on one side" of the border and condemned "the lack of even working hours on the other (Israeli) side", who often "knock off at four in the afternoon".

"It is nonsense and it's part of the malicious lying on the Israeli side to deny starvation and to blame the UN".

She recalled a trip to Somalia during the famine there in the 1990s, and "what it means when you have a severely malnourished child".

But in Somalia those children "were getting exactly the medical aid" they needed.

"There are 325,000 severely malnourished children in Gaza today," Mrs Robinson said, adding: "I don't know how many of them will die before September."

She said that "there are stockpiles ready to go", and that "tomorrow they could flood Gaza with necesssary food".

Mrs Robinson insisted that trade with Israeli is "crucial".


Read more:

Israel steps up Gaza City attacks, 123 reported dead in 24 hour


She called on the EU "to implement the commitment under Article 2 of the Israeli-EU trade agreement, and stop the preferential trade" with Israel.

The fact that three G7 countries are going to recognise Palestine in September "is really important".

She also called on the League of Arab States "to step up".

Asked of the prospects for a ceasefire, she said: "If President Trump would put some of his political energy behind it, it would happen."

"We know that... he's the man that can do things fairly instantly."

Meanwhile, a Hamas official has said that Israeli forces were making "aggressive" incursions into Gaza City, after the military approved the framework for a new offensive in the territory.

President Michael D Higgins said today that the comments on Gaza made by the Elders "deserve the widest possible circulation".

"The world will thank the Elders for the valuable comments that they have made following a visit to Egypt and the Rafah border crossing by the former President of Ireland and former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson and the former Prime Minister of New Zealand Helen Clark," he said in a statement.

"President Robinson and Helen Clark are authoritative figures on famine, hunger and the role of the United Nations. Their statements draw attention to the 325,000 children malnourished in Gaza and at risk of death before the end of September.

"President Robinson is also right to draw attention to the special treatment needed for malnutrition, drawing on her experience in Somalia in 1992."