skip to main content

Court hears questions over DNA evidence in Hutch murder trial

James Quinn is facing life imprisonment over the murder of Gary Hutch (Pictures courtesy EFE)
James Quinn is facing life imprisonment over the murder of Gary Hutch (Pictures courtesy EFE)

A Spanish court hearing the trial of a Dublin man for the murder of Gary Hutch in September 2015 has heard questions over DNA evidence obtained from a baseball cap.

James Quinn, 35, is facing life imprisonment over the murder of Mr Hutch, who was shot 15 times on 24 September 2015.

Mr Quinn is accused of shooting the 34-year-old in the head twice from close range after allegedly chasing him around the Angel de Miraflores residential estate in Mijas.

In the second day of the trial, five witnesses testified in front of a jury and judge Ernesto Carlos Manzano at La Ciudad de la Justicia court in Malaga.

Police investigators and the prosecution counsel, Jose Barba, claimed a baseball cap that tested positive for Mr Quinn's DNA has been a 'main player' in identifying the Dubliner as the perpetrator of the crime, which he was arrested for in September 2016.

Officials revealed they had obtained the defendant's DNA after an undercover officer took a water bottle Mr Quinn had been drinking from at a train station in Madrid in July 2016.

In CCTV footage from the estate on the day of the murder, the prosecution claims the attacker is first seen wearing a baseball cap, which he changes to a balaclava before attacking Mr Hutch.

Defence counsel Pedro Apalategui argued: "When I studied the still images, it [the cap] wasn't in a single one of them."

The defence highlighted that in the first official police report from the crime, there was no mention of the baseball cap.

He questioned why it was not brought to attention or registered in reports until Mr Quinn's DNA had been obtained almost a year after the incident.

A Civil Guard chief involved in the investigation, who testified via video conference, claimed that the baseball cap had simply not been noticed in the footage earlier.

"Is it true that from July 2016 you started to mention a still frame in which Quinn wears a cap?" Mr Apalategui asked.

The Civil Guard chief responded that they could not include all still images from the CCTV - of which there were thousands - and chose the most important frames at the beginning of the investigation.

"He was wearing a cap from the beginning. We have included it because it is an important part … Not because it wasn't there before," he responded.

Two witnesses, a resident at the apartment complex and a grounds worker who were present on the day of the attack, testified anonymously behind a door in a separate room.

Both claimed they did not see a cap at any point - but mentioned that they saw the attacker wearing a balaclava and a zip up hoodie.

Jurors were presented with evidence recovered from the BMW getaway car, which was set on fire near Marbella after the attack on Hutch.

Items included a pair of runners - of which only the soles remained - two gloves, a charred hat that crumbled in the hands of jurors, a zip-up hoody and a black cap.

All but the black baseball cap were either partially or completely burnt.

The forensic official said: "Some items were covered by others on top - like layers.

"The parts that were on the top received more heat and burnt more, the ones in the middle less so and the ones on the bottom were almost completely fine, like the cap."

The prosecution and investigating officers revealed how the murder has triggered the Kinahan-Hutch feud, after discovering various clues that they allege link Mr Quinn to the Kinahan gang.

A testifying police officer claimed after the getaway BMW car was set on fire, two Romanian brothers who had allegedly been staying at Mr Quinn's home close to Marbella, picked him up from the scene in a car they believe belonged to Daniel Kinahan's late mother.

The brothers were both arrested but dismissed at a later date.

Another piece of evidence that officers believed was a "clear link" was a photograph of Mr Kinahan's mother found in Mr Quinn's wallet when he was arrested at Madrid Barajas airport in September 2016.

During a telephone conversation in August 2016, investigators claimed Mr Quinn admitted "he already knew" about a "failed" assassination attempt in Mallorca that same month before it was publicly revealed in which Irishman Trevor O'Neill was killed.

Mr O'Neill was not the intended target and it is believed the crime was related to the Kinahan-Hutch gangland feud.