skip to main content

Man sentenced to indefinite hospital order over Irishman's murder

Thomas O'Halloran was originally from Ennistymon, Co Clare
Thomas O'Halloran was originally from Ennistymon, Co Clare

An ex-prisoner has been hospitalised indefinitely for the "senseless" killing of an elderly Irishman in London five days after his release.

Hunger Games-obsessed Lee Byer was psychotic when he stabbed 87-year-old Thomas O'Halloran in the neck and chest in Greenford, west London, in August 2022.

Mr O'Halloran, who used a mobility scooter, was originally from Ennistymon, Co Clare.

Byer later wrote repeatedly about a "Hunger Games" scenario in which he was required to meet "contestants" and then fight or attack, the Old Bailey was told.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences


Five days before the killing, Byer, who had a string of convictions, was released from Wormwood Scrubs, having served a full 12-year sentence for robbery.

Prosecutor Gareth Patterson KC told the court: "Technically, he was on bail when he was released in August 2022, so these offences were committed while on bail. Some months later that allegation was discontinued."

"From accounts from his mother and brother, there was odd behaviour but at that stage the full nature and degree of his mental illness had not been diagnosed."

The 45-year-old, of no fixed address, denied murder but pleaded guilty to the lesser offence of manslaughter by diminished responsibility and having an offensive weapon.

The pleas were accepted by the prosecution after mental health reports found Byer was psychotic, hearing voices, suffering from paranoid delusions and paranoid schizophrenia.

A court sketch of Lee Byer from August 2022

Killing of popular accordion player 'horrified' community

The fatal stabbing has left a whole community "shocked" and "horrified", police said.

Detective Inspector Laura Nelson told the PA news agency that the death of Mr O'Halloran had a "huge impact".

"His loss is felt greatly within his family," Ms Nelson said.

"He certainly showed no signs of slowing down in his old age. He was head of the family. He looked after his family, cared for them.

"He enjoyed playing his accordion and he was very well known throughout the community for that.

"I think the community were just shocked. Really, really horrified."

She said she hopes the conclusion of the case will bring "justice" for the family.

The prosecution had "carefully considered" the case before accepting Byer's plea to manslaughter in light of the medical reports.

Ms Nelson said the sentence of a hospital order would help protect the public.

"Ultimately, we've got to think about public safety and rehabilitation. Lee Byer will get the treatment that he needs in order to enable him hopefully to be well, so that protects in the future," she said.

On the defendant's criminal history, Ms Nelson said: "We know that he'd been released from prison five days prior to the attack.

"He'd been sentenced and had been recalled on licence for a robbery offence."

The earlier recall to prison had been over a "harassment matter" and breaching a non-molestation order, she added.

Thomas O'Halloran playing his accordion outside a Tesco in London

On 16 August 2022, Mr O'Halloran had travelled on his mobility scooter with his accordion on a shopping trip to Tesco.

As he made his way home, Byer left his address and the pair crossed paths in an underpass on the A40.

Ms Nelson, who led the Scotland Yard investigation, said: "Lee Byer attacked Thomas O'Halloran for absolutely no reason. There was no motive for it."

She said emergency services were alerted within two minutes of the "brutal attack".

The officer said: "It was a very fast-paced investigation. I had a team of people specifically working on trying to track the suspect's movements from CCTV.

"We were fortunate that the area had very good coverage. We saw Byer exit the underpass still carrying a knife at this point. He had also got some gloves on."

Police followed his progress through the subway and under the A40.

Soon after that, Ms Nelson said the face mask Byer was wearing fell down and he was seen to dispose of an item in a drain which turned out to be a handle.

The clear image of the suspect was circulated in the media with an "immediate" response from the public naming Byer, she said.

Meanwhile, the handle Byer had dumped in a drain was examined and found to have the DNA from both the victim and Byer on it.

Of the defendant, Ms Nelson said: "He was an unusual character. He denied the offence. Upon his arrest, he continued to deny being involved in the offence.

"Even when presented with the wealth of evidence that we were able to put to him, he still disputed his involvement.

"What we now know through a number of medical assessments is that he was psychotic."