Analysis: Much will hinge on the fashion brand's ability to both reconnect with its original audience and resonate with Gen-Z shoppers
By Rose Marroncelli, Nottingham Trent University
During the 2000s and 2010s, Topshop was a fashion powerhouse and an icon of the high street. A combination of music, make-up and the latest fashions allowed the retailer to thrive in popularity. High profile celebrity collaborations with model Kate Moss and singer Beyoncé also raised Topshop's profile in a crowded retail market.
The retailer was renowned for being "cool", fostering design collaborations with up-and-coming designers, including JW Anderson, Marques' Almedia and Christopher Kane. The models which fronted campaigns were also "it girls", such as models Lily Cole and Cara Delevingne and actor Kate Bosworth.
From Understitch, the rise and fall of Topshop
However, the brand's success did not prove sustainable. In 2020, its owner, the Arcadia group, entered administration and all physical stores closed shortly thereafter. The brand's reputation was further damaged by allegations of financial mishandling surrounding its owner, Philip Green. Green was also accused of poor treatment towards Arcadia staff, but has always denied any unlawful behaviour.
The online retailer, Asos, acquired Topshop in 2021 and continued to sell its clothes online. However, in 2024, Asos sold a 75% stake of the Topshop brand, in order to repay debts. The majority is now owned by Danish company, Bestseller.
Changing consumer shopping habits, predominantly the rise in online shopping, contributed to Topshop's downfall. But Topshop was not the only high street retailer that struggled to keep up in the digital age. In recent years, Debenhams, Ted Baker and Claire's have all gone into administration. House of Fraser has also announced multiple store closures. With an ever increasing number of empty units on the high street, the news that Topshop is planning a return, with physical stores, may come as a surprise to some.
From RTÉ News, Topshop will make its return to the Irish high street with a shop in Co Donegal.
In August, Topshop returned to the runway with its first catwalk show for seven years, in London's Trafalgar Square. The show was deemed a success, and "the comeback show of the year", according to critics including Rolling Stone. Demonstrating the brand's ability to embrace the digital era, a "see-now, buy-now" approach let audiences shop for pieces instantly. The catwalk show set the backdrop for the relaunch, and managing director Michelle Wilson confirmed that standalone stores would be returning to the high street.
Can this high street plan be a success? The same struggles exist as they did when Topshop closed all physical stores in 2020. High rents and running costs remain a challenge, and the popularity of online shopping continues to grow. Online brands such as Temu and Shein offer the latest styles at low prices. This is known as "ultra-fast fashion", and appeals to younger consumers.
From Sky News, Topshop celebrates relaunch with first catwalk show in seven years
However, research has suggested that Gen-Z are becoming sensitive to the issue of unsustainable production practices, which are widely reported at both brands. It may be the case that in an increasingly digital world, there remains a need for physical retail spaces, where consumers can touch garments and interact with their peers.
Global market research firm Mintel notes how successful retail spaces are evolving to provide more than just products. This is known as experiential retail and includes creating spaces for socialising, learning and community events. Gymshark is an example of an online active-wear brand that followed these retail recommendations when opening its flagship store in Regent Street, London, in 2023. In addition to garments, the Regent Street store offers gym classes, running clubs and personal training sessions..
If the brand can combine the latest fashions with sustainability, experiential retail and digital integration, it does have the potential to thrive once more
Can Topshop create a new physical space which consumers will want to pay repeat visits? The original consumer base from the 2000s and 2010s have now grown up, and are in a different life phase. However, research has shown that consumers can display strong emotional connections with retro brands, which may work for Topshop.
A successful return to the high street will hinge on its ability to balance nostalgia with innovation. Reviving emotional connections with its original audience while resonating with Gen-Z will be crucial. If the brand can combine the latest fashions with sustainability, experiential retail and digital integration, it does have the potential to thrive once more.
Follow RTÉ Brainstorm on WhatsApp and Instagram for more stories and updates
Rose Marroncelli is a Lecturer in fashion marketing, management and communication at Nottingham Trent University. This article was originally published by The Conversation.
The views expressed here are those of the author and do not represent or reflect the views of RTÉ
