Analysis: Early science fiction imagined smart homes as liberating, but such portrayals have now shifted from utopian to dystopian
The concept of a smart home is one that might have sounded quite far-fetched to many of us even ten years ago. Indeed, if this article was written then, it would probably have begun with an explanation of the term and discussed the homes of people in niche tech circles. Today, though, the smart home has gone from a futuristic novelty to a mainstream reality. In fact, Ireland seems to be ahead of the curve in this regard, with 81% of Irish homes adopting some forms of smart home technology.
While the ability to control your heating, lights, or security system with just a tap on your phone is now commonplace, for a long time, this level of automation and convenience was the stuff of science fiction. It's here, within the realm of science fiction, where we find an interesting development in the way we think about smart homes and imagine their implications. As we embrace this technology, it's important to reflect on how the portrayal of smart homes in media has shifted — from utopian dreams of convenience to dystopian warnings about privacy and control.
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
From RTÉ News, CSO report tat the use of smart technology in Irish homes is on the rise
In early representations, science fiction imagined smart homes as liberating, freeing their occupants from mundane tasks. These futuristic homes symbolised technological progress and a better quality of life. However, as the smart home has become a reality, more recent portrayals in science fiction have grown darker, reflecting societal concerns about surveillance, data privacy, and losing control over our own spaces.
The cultural fascination with the smart home was largely cemented during the 1950s and 60s. Reflecting a post-war optimism and the birth of the American dream, the science fiction of this period was filled with fantastical homes of the future, where a life of leisure is made possible by creative new inventions and technologies. Films and shows like Forbidden Planet (1956) and Star Trek (1966-1969) not only introduced audiences to strange new worlds, but also to futuristic visions of the home where advanced technology played a central role in everyday life.
From Warner Bros Classics, the theme tune and intro to The Jetsons
One of the most famous examples of this is the cartoon series, The Jetsons (1962-1963). This typical nuclear family lived in a fully automated home equipped with robotic maids, moving walkways, and voice-activated appliances, all designed to minimise effort and maximise comfort. This reflected the prevailing belief of the period that technological innovation could lead to a life of ease and luxury, freeing people from the drudgery of household chores and ushering in a new era of domestic bliss.
The depictions of the smart home in science fiction also created expectations of a future where technology would seamlessly integrate into everyday life. This expectation shaped consumer aspirations and desires, driving a demand for products that promised to make life easier and more efficient.
The "House of Tomorrow" quickly made its way into advertising and exhibitions, notably at Disney's Tomorrowland in the 1950s and 1960s, which showcased futuristic homes filled with labour-saving appliances and gadgets, including automated kitchens, self-cleaning ovens, and even robotic vacuum cleaners. While these devices may seem relatively low-tech by today's standards, they were largely influenced by the science fiction narratives of the time and reflected a tangible sense of utopianism regarding the integration of technology into the home.
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
From RTÉ Radio 1's Today with Claire Byrne, Are smart homes money saved or money wasted?
Today, the smart home of science fiction is largely a reality. While we've welcomed these technologies into our homes, the portrayal of the smart home in contemporary science fiction suggests that we haven’t done so with the enthusiasm of the 1950s. Instead, our current imagination for the future of this technology reflects an underlying distrust.
It’s no secret that the apps used to control smart appliances gather vast amounts of personal data, data which is then sold to advertisers. Many of us are happy to trade off a little privacy for a more convenient lifestyle. However, the drastic change in the depiction of the smart home in film and television reveals a lingering air of unease with this loss of privacy, as the home now risks becoming a surveillance zone, monitored by the same corporations that sell us these devices.
Trailer for Ex Machina
It's no coincidence that this shift in the public imagination comes about just as these technologies are becoming available. Released the same year as Amazon's Alexa, Alex Garland’s Ex Machina (2014) tells the story of Caleb, a software engineer who is invited to his boss’s AI controlled home to test a new android he has created, named Ava. As the film reveals, however, Ava has been gathering information on Caleb. She eventually uses this to manipulate him into freeing her, while she traps him inside the house using the automated security system.
Black Mirror is full of depictions of nefarious technology, but the White Christmas (2014) episode is particularly chilling. It imagines a world where people's consciousnesses are uploaded into a smart home system, trapping digital clones in perpetual servitude, as they effectively become the very products they once controlled. Both of these examples share none of the optimism of earlier science fiction and instead reveal a certain anxiety surrounding surveillance and the loss of privacy and autonomy in the once private sanctum of the home.
Read more: The rise of the all-seeing smart doorbell in our towns and cities
The evolution of the smart home from a symbol of convenience and luxury to an instrument of surveillance and control reflects our complex relationship with technology. While we enjoy the efficiency that smart home devices bring, science fiction reminds us of the costs of this convenience: diminished privacy, data exploitation, and a creeping loss of autonomy.
As we continue to integrate these technologies into our daily lives, we are urged to ask ourselves whether the convenience offered by smart home technology is worth the potential sacrifices to our privacy and independence. How much control are we willing to cede for the sake of comfort, and where should we draw the line between innovation and intrusion?
Follow RTÉ Brainstorm on WhatsApp and Instagram for more stories and updates
The views expressed here are those of the author and do not represent or reflect the views of RTÉ
