skip to main content

South Korea accuses Nissan of manipulating emissions data on its Qashqai SUV

South Korea says Nissan's Qashqai had a device to make its emissions appear lower than they actually were
South Korea says Nissan's Qashqai had a device to make its emissions appear lower than they actually were

South Korea has it will fine Nissan for manipulating emissions data on a popular diesel sports utility vehicle, bringing the Japanese car giant into a widening global scandal that has already ensnared Volkswagen and Mitsubishi.

Seoul said it would order recalls of hundreds of Qashqai model SUVs after it said that tests had revealed an emission defeat system that made the vehicle appear to be less polluting than it really was; though Nissan has denied the existence of such a device or of any emissions data manipulation.

South Korea's decision follows an investigation into 20 diesel-powered cars last December, initiated by Seoul after German carmaker Volkswagen admitted to having installed devices aimed at cheating emissions tests into 11 million diesel engines.

Nissan would be fined 330 million won ($280,000), the environment ministry said.

"Our investigation... concluded that Nissan illegally manipulated emission data," the ministry said in a statement.

Hong Dong-Kon, a ministry official handling transport-related regulations, added: "A group of auto industry experts we consulted with also agreed that this is a clear manipulation of emission data." 

State tests showed the Qashqai switched off its emission reduction device when the car temperature reached 35 degrees Celsius to stop the vehicle from overheating, whereas other cars waited until the temperature reached 50 degrees.

The ministry also said that when the Qashqai's emissions reduction device stopped working, the level of emissions was about the same or higher than the Volkswagen's cars equipped with emissions-cheating software systems.

However Nissan has denied the claim, saying it does not manipulate emissions data from its vehicles.

The company also denied that it had fit a device to cheat emissions tests, and said tests conducted by authorities in the European Union backed up that stance.

"Although the conclusions reached by the Korean authorities are inconsistent with those of other regulators, Nissan will carefully assess and consider appropriate next steps," the firm said in a statement.

"Nissan is committed to upholding the law and meeting or exceeding regulations in every market where we operate. We are continuing to work with the Korean authorities.”

Unlike its rivals Volkswagen and Mitsubishi, Nissan - Japan's number two automaker - has so far avoided being embroiled in any emissions or fuel economy cheating scandals.

Mitsubishi last month admitted it had been falsifying fuel-economy tests for years, manipulating data to make cars seem more efficient than they were in reality.

The scandal includes mini-cars produced by Mitsubishi for Nissan as part of a joint venture, but Nissan is said to have had no part in the cheating.

Nissan threw a surprise lifeline to Mitsubishi last week by offering to buy 34% of its shares, but its top executive warned Friday that he would kill the $2.2 billion offer if the Mitsubishi scandal spreads beyond Japan.

Nissan will be given ten days to present its opinions on the Qashqai issue before Seoul officially carries out punitive measures, the environment ministry said.