Home News TV Listings Movies Music Video Photos Radio Book Club Life & Style

Movie Review

The Summit

Reviewer Rating
User Rating

Director: Nick Ryan

Starring: Sherpa Pemba Gyalje, Wilco Van Roijen, JJ McDonnell, Cecile Skog, Hoselito Bite,Pat Falvey.

Duration: 95 minutes

Certificate 12A

1 of 4 The Summit was funded by Bord Scannán na hÉireann/ the Irish Film Board, RTE, BAI and BBC. K2
The Summit was funded by Bord Scannán na hÉireann/ the Irish Film Board, RTE, BAI and BBC. K2
2 of 4 Sherpa Pemba Gyalje, a leading contributor to this moving documentary
Sherpa Pemba Gyalje, a leading contributor to this moving documentary
3 of 4 K2 in the Himalayas, the second highest peak and the most dangerous mountain on Earth
K2 in the Himalayas, the second highest peak and the most dangerous mountain on Earth
4 of 4 K2 and the forbidding majesty of the Himalayas, as revisited in The Summit
K2 and the forbidding majesty of the Himalayas, as revisited in The Summit

The Summit is a profoundly captivating film which recalls a terrible tragedy. However, it is also a film which, without trying too hard, salutes simple acts of human bravery and loyalty. It makes the viewer ponder the dilemmas that mountaineers face, when trouble strikes. For instance, do you stay to try and help, or descend to save your own life, as lack of oxygen takes its toll and frostbite is a definite possibility if you don’t get to camp quickly? That is just one of many moral or tactical dilemmas that surround such adventure.

The catastrophic events recalled and dramatically recreated in The Summit with such ice-cold clarity occurred on August 1, 2008. That summer, more than 70 climbers from 15 expeditions attempted K2, in the Himalayas, the second highest peak on Earth at 8,611km.  Eleven climbers, including Limerick man, Ger McDonnell, lost their lives.

Historically, most casualties occur during the descent of K2, as the memorials at the base of the mountain, which is situated at the Pakistan-China border readily testify. One out of every four people who reach the summit has died on the way down - one wrong step and you are history, as one climber puts it.

Yet when others had descended, Ger McDonnell stayed to help two or three injured Koreans.  A precarious, overhang of ice, known as a serac, over 100m high, collapsed on this brave Irishman and the South Koreans, causing their deaths.  His brother JJ, and his partner, Annie Starkey recall the 36-year old Ger, who was clearly a charismatic individual, full of fun and gutsiness. Shortly before his death, he was recorded on film at the summit, saying he was so happy he could almost cry. Ger McDonnell was the first Irishman to reach the summit of the so-called `Savage Mountain.’

There is footage of Ger singing the Rocky Road to Dublin in a tent, his arm around Sherpa Pemba Gyalje. Pemba, an interesting contributor to the film, is a highly-focused mountaineer who is key to the facts of the tragedy, in so far as they are known. A certain degree of mystery and controversy still dog the tragedy, five years on.

The bottleneck formed by a rock-lined corridor saw the start of the trouble, as the climbers ran out of daylight. Two hours later than scheduled, they were immobilised below the summit, waiting in a queue to pass individually through. The first casualty was the Serbian climber who slipped to his death, accidentally hitting a Norwegian climber, Cecile Skog. She would lose her husband,Rolf Bae, hours later. Fixed ropes that had been screwed into the snow - vital lifelines for the climbers -  were cut by the fall of snow that killed Rolf.

The Summit celebrates the fearsome majesty of K2 and that shot of its pyramid-like shadow reflected in the sky above China is a beautiful, yet baleful motif throughout.

Paddy Kehoe

add your own comment
User contributions and/or comments do not, unless specifically stated, represent the views of RTÉ.ie or RTÉ.
Click here for Terms of use