Music News
X Factor cleared over Minogue comments
Monday 23 November 2009
The show, broadcast last month, saw Johnson give a performance of 'And I'm Telling You I'm Not Going', which was originally composed as a female lead vocal for the musical Dreamgirls.
In her critique, judge Minogue said the singer had given a "true 'X Factor' performance" but added: "If we're to believe everything we read in the papers, maybe you didn't need to change the gender reference in it?"
Fellow judge Simon Cowell said Minogue was playing "games" and she later apologised to anyone who may have been offended saying of her comments: "They were only said with humour."
The regulator Ofcom said it received nearly 4,000 complaints, the majority of which were concerned that Minogue's remarks were malicious and homophobic and based on newspaper reports about Johnson's sexuality.
Some viewers were concerned that Minogue seemed to be referring to the contestant's sexuality in a pre-watershed family show.
Those in charge of compliance emphasised the show is live and unscripted and Minogue's comments had been prompted by discussions in a video-taped introduction to the performance about changing the gender of the song.
Johnson also said in a statement that he was not offended by Minogue's comment, saying they chatted afterwards.
The regulator found: "In Ofcom's view, it was not outside the established nature of the programme for an 'X Factor' judge to make such a comment as Dannii Minogue's especially in circumstances where the performer had placed information about his sexuality in the public domain...
"Ofcom did not discern a pejorative or homophobic intent behind her comment."
The regulator found the show was not in breach of broadcasting rules and the reference to Johnson's sexuality was made only indirectly and was therefore unlikely to shock viewers.
But it warned broadcasters generally to exercise caution over rules concerning sexual orientation and violation of human dignity.
Ofcom said: "Broadcasters need to exercise caution in this area, particularly when the subject of sexual orientation may foreseeably arise in the context of a live programme.
"In no way should the 'outing' of participants in television programmes be encouraged, condoned or legitimised."
Click here for Terms of use
|
Top 10 Most Read
Must Watch TV
-
- The Late Late Show
You can be guaranteed that Ryan Tubridy will host a stellar line-up of high-profile guests, current social issues will get an airing and he'll introduce the very best in all-round entertainment, plus a fabulous prize for someone at home! What more could you ask for from your Friday night viewing?
-
- Who Knows Ireland Best?
Derek Mooney hosts as two teams compete to see who is most in touch and who has their finger on the pulse. Points are awarded for being in agreement with the majority of a survey of 1,000 people across the country. This week, three agricultural consultants (Tom Dawson, Tipperary; Julie Roche, Cork; and Mike Brady, Cork) go head-to-head with three auctioneers (Nora Meaney, Sharon O'Leary and Maura Fenlon, all from Carlow) to see who is more in tune with the nation.
-
- The Big C
As the rest of the neighbourhood gets ready for Hallowe'en, Cathy prepares to start a clinical trial she hopes will cure her cancer. Yet just when Cathy needs him, Paul has to deal with a series of problems at work. And as they are arriving at the hospital, Cathy's search for a parking spot ends with her harmlessly hitting another patient with her car. Meanwhile, as Adam grows increasingly agitated by his mom's illness, Sean's Hallowe'en plans lead him to suspect that Marlene's ghost is haunting his house.
-
- Hustle
Albert decides to pay a nostalgic visit to an old haunt, only to find it's been pulled down by ruthless property tycoon and former '80s game show host, Dale Ridley (played by Mark Williams) in this week's episode. Posing as international businessmen, the team lure Dale into a scam, convincing him to purchase the television studios that fired him in his showbiz heyday on their behalf. Will the temptation to get revenge on his old employers be enough to trick the greedy entrepreneur?
-
- Safari Vet School
Thirty-two vet students are at one of the toughest vet schools in the world in the Eastern Cape of South Africa. Under the guiding hand of Chief Vet, Dr Will Fowlds, the students tackle everything from lions to rhinos to giraffes and elephants. In tonight's episode, TV vet Steve Leonard who presents the show is pushed to his limits when he's left in charge of 16 vet students and a hall of 100 barking dogs while Cambridge student Nadia gets a second chance at being a team leader.