Home News TV Listings Movies Music Video Photos Radio Extra Book Club RTÉ Guide

Media News

Walsh highlights pressure on acts

'X Factor' judge Louis Walsh believes contestants on the show such as Scott James, who has Asperger's syndrome, may not be able to cope - but says it must be their choice whether to take part.
1 of 1 Louis Walsh pictured with the other X Factor judges
Louis Walsh pictured with the other X Factor judges

21-year-old James who will appear on TV screens in the new series of 'X Factor', told judges he did not leave home for seven years because of his condition.

Speaking to the Radio Times, Walsh was asked if someone like James can take the strain of appearing on the programme.

He said: "I don't think they can, if I'm honest. People don't realise the pressure that these acts are under, especially when they're competing with everybody else backstage.

"It's a very difficult show to do, even as a judge. It's very gruelling, and it's 10 weeks of very intense performance. Everything you say and do is being watched. It's like Big Brother meets Jerry Springer."

Asked if it was fair on James, from Stockton-on-Tees, to allow him to appear, Walsh told the magazine: "Nobody forces anybody to go to an audition.

"I think it's a real-life story. Is he under too much pressure? I think it has to be his choice."

Asked if James knew what he was letting himself in for, Walsh said: "Initially, no," adding: "I think it's a massive reality check for some people."

Despite not appearing on TV yet, James has already been tipped as a singing sensation to rival Susan Boyle

Walsh's comments follow Boyle's much-publicised breakdown after coming second on Britain's Got Talent, which fuelled debate about whether people seen as vulnerable for whatever reason should take part in reality shows.

add your own comment
User contributions and/or comments do not, unless specifically stated, represent the views of RTÉ.ie or RTÉ.
Click here for Terms of use

Must Watch TV

  • - The Irish Film and Television Awards
    Simon Delaney: back again to host the IFTAs

    9.40pm RTÉ One

    Simon Delaney hosts as the biggest star-studded event in the Irish calendar gets held at the Convention Centre Dublin, with the likes of Glenn Close, Michael Fassbender and Maria Doyle Kennedy all nominated. The features nominated for Best Film at IFTA 2012 are the period drama Albert Nobbs; Irish psychological thriller Charlie Casanova; black comedy The Guard, and rural drama Stella Days. Even if you're watching at home, it's recommended that you dress accordingly and leave a red mat outside your front door.

  • - The Jonathan Ross Show
    Jonathan Ross: Denzel Washington is among this week's guests

    9.15pm UTV

    On the show this week, Jonathan welcomes a host of acting talent: double Oscar winner, Denzel Washington, Keira Knightley, and British hardman-turned-Hollywood hunk, Tom Hardy. To top it all he's got the legendary Dionne Warwick singing live in the studio.

  • - Take Me Out
    Paddy McGuinness: more date-dealing for 30 single girls

    8.00pm UTV

    What do you mean 'It's rubbish!'? Of course it's rubbish, but that doesn't mean you can't enjoy it. The irrepressible Paddy McGuinness tries to arrange more dates for his line-up of 30 single girls. Descending from the love lift this time around are: a farmer from Devon, a management consultant from Hull, a young Conservative from Manchester and a London architecture student. You can also see how the couples from last week survived the Isle of Fernando's.

  • - All Star Family Fortunes
    Vernon Kay: back for more Family Fortunes

    6.00pm UTV

    The classic family game show that stretches all the way back to the '70s returns for another run, starting off with teams consisting of TV presenter Carol Vorderman and her family playing astrologer (and Strictly Come Dancing contestant) Russell Grant and his family. Hosted by Vernon Kay, both celebrities and their families go head to head for the big money, and the chance to win up to a five-figure sum for the charity of their choice.

  • - Casualty
    Casualty: another busy night at Holby General

    9.20pm, BBC ONE

    Plenty of high drama at Holby General's A&E department as Zoe tries to convince Sam to sit down and talk to Keith Parr before he brings an action against Sam and the hospital. A troubled woman is brought into the ED after being hit by a lorry and Lloyd is quick to jump to conclusions about the driver. Meanwhile Linda has a chance to examine her feelings when Lenny tackles her about putting her niece and nephew into care.