China targets browser, media player in Microsoft competition probe

Tuesday 26 August 2014 08.10
China is raising the same issues investigated by US and European authorities in the early 2000s
China is raising the same issues investigated by US and European authorities in the early 2000s

Microsoft’s internet browser and media player are being targeted in a Chinese competition probe, raising the prospect of China revisiting the software bundling issue at the heart of past complaints against the firm in the West.

Microsoft has not been fully transparent with information about its Windows and Office sales, but has expressed willingness to cooperate with ongoing investigations, Zhang Mao, the head of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce, told reporters at a briefing in Beijing today.

As Windows became the world's dominant operating system in the 1990s and 2000s, the issue of how Microsoft bundled its web browser and media player became the focus of respective competition cases brought by US and European authorities.

Microsoft settled in 2001 with the US Department of Justice a long-running case centring around whether it could bundle its flagship Internet Explorer browser with Windows.

In 2004, the European Union ordered Microsoft to pay a €497m fine and produce a version of Windows without the Windows Media Player bundled. 

The fine was later increased to nearly €1.4bn.

China's focus on two products previously litigated elsewhere appears to form the basis of its investigation, but the probe could extend beyond the media player and browser bundling issue, said You Youting, a partner at Shanghai Debund Law Offices.

"It's possible the government hasn't been successful in finding what they're looking for," You said. "But by starting with these two products, it gives them time."

A Microsoft spokesman declined to comment when contacted by telephone.

The Microsoft investigation comes amid a spate of antitrust probes against foreign firms in China, including mobile chipset maker Qualcomm and German car maker Daimler AG's luxury auto unit Mercedes-Benz. 

The probes have renewed fears of Chinese protectionism.

The SAIC said earlier this month that Microsoft had been suspected of violating China's anti-monopoly law since June last year in relation to problems with compatibility, bundling and document authentication for its Windows operating system and Microsoft Office software.

The SAIC, one of China's three anti-monopoly regulators, formally announced its investigation into Microsoft's activities this month after officials raided Microsoft offices in several major cities and met Microsoft Deputy General Counsel Mary Snapp for questioning in Beijing.

"The investigation is presently ongoing, and we will disclose the results to the public in a timely fashion," Zhang said, adding that the probe is one of nine opened this year which include the software, tobacco, telecommunications, insurance, tourism and utilities sectors.

The companies involved in the nine investigations comprise domestic, foreign, state-owned enterprises and trade associations, Zhang said.