Underwear Bomber has life sentence upheld

Monday 13 January 2014 23.23
Abdulmutallab pleaded guilty at his trial in Detroit in 2011
Abdulmutallab pleaded guilty at his trial in Detroit in 2011

A Nigerian man who tried to set off an explosive hidden in his underwear while aboard a US airliner on Christmas Day in 2009 has had his life sentence upheld by a federal appeals court.

The 6th US Circuit Court of Appeals rejected arguments by Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, known as the Underwear Bomber, that the sentence was cruel and unusual punishment, and that US District Judge Nancy Edmunds had erred by letting him represent himself at trial despite doubt about his competency.

Abdulmutallab, 27, challenged the sentence despite having pleaded guilty in October 2011, one day after his trial began.

He called his attempted bombing at the time a part of his "religious duty" to participate in a jihad against the United States to avenge attacks on Muslims.

The defendant had been trained at an al Qaeda camp in Yemen under the direction of US-born Muslim cleric Anwar al-Awlaki.

Writing for a three-judge panel, Circuit Judge David McKeague called Abdulmutallab an "educated and adept individual" who chose a "deliberate, conscious, and complicated path" in the name of martyrdom.

He said a life sentence was appropriate given the nature of the crime, and the defendant's having committed an act of terrorism and "communicated a desire" to undertake more.

Mr McKeague also found no reason to question Abdulmutallab's competence. "The complexity behind Abdulmutallab's mission indicates the exact opposite of incompetence," he wrote.

The bomb set off by the defendant caused a fire but failed to explode on Northwest Airlines Flight 253, operated by Delta Air Lines Inc, to Detroit from Amsterdam with 289 people aboard.

Passengers quickly subdued Abdulmutallab, and the plane landed a few minutes later.

Prosecutors said Abdulmutallab had traveled to Yemen a few months before the flight, and it was there that he had agreed to conduct a suicide bombing of a US airliner over the United States.

Abdulmutallab was originally represented by a federal public defender but later chose to represent himself.

In his appeal, the defendant had also challenged the admission of incriminating statements he had made shortly after the flight at a University of Michigan hospital.           

The 6th Circuit said that by pleading guilty, Abdulmutallab waived his right to challenge the statements' admissibility.

Barbara McQuade, the US Attorney in Detroit, said in a statement: "We are glad that the defendant's life sentence has been upheld and that he will never have another opportunity to kill innocent victims."