• RTÉ.ie
  • News
  • Sport
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Life & Style
  • RTÉ Player
  • Television
  • Radio
  • Orchestras
  • More
  • RTÉ Live
  • RTÉ News Now
  • RTÉ Radio Player
  • RTÉ Aertel
  • RTÉ Apps
  • Weather
  • Fashion
  • Food
  • Motors
  • Travel
  • Homes
  • Classifieds
  • RTÉ Mobile
  • Performing Groups
  • Lotto
  • Jobs
  • About
  • Shop
  • RTÉjr
  • TRTÉ
  • RTÉ Archives
  • Feedback
  • RTÉ Digital Blog
    • Home
    • Ireland
    • World
    • Business
    • Watch & Listen
    • Special Reports
    • Galleries
    • Money
    • Programmes
    TV Programmes
    • One News
    • Six One News
    • Nine News
    • News On Two
    • Oireachtas Report
    • Prime Time
    • The Frontline
    • Nuacht
    • One to One
    • The Week In Politics
    • European Parliament Report
    • news2day
    Radio Programmes
    • Morning Ireland
    • News At One
    • Drivetime
    • This Week
    • World Report
    • Late Debate

    17-year-old seeking abortion challenges HSE

    Updated: 12:18, Wednesday, 02 May 2007
    Tweet
    • Article
    High Court - Leave to travel sought
    High Court - Leave to travel sought

    The High Court is to hear a challenge by a 17-year-old girl against a Health Service Executive decision to stop her leaving the State for an abortion.

    The 17-year-old, who has been told that her child cannot survive outside the womb, has been in the care of the HSE since February.

    'Miss D' is four months pregnant and wants to travel to the UK for a termination.

    The decision was made when the teenager discovered the baby she is carrying is suffering from anencephaly, a condition which is causing its brain not to develop properly.

    She has been told that the child will only live a very short time, if at all, after it is born.

    The HSE is refusing to allow her to leave the country.

    Miss D is challenging the court order placing her in care, in so far as it restricts her leaving the State.

    She is also asking the High Court to overrule the HSE's decision to ask gardaí to stop her.

    And she is challenging the HSE's decision to refuse to let her travel to terminate the pregnancy unless there was a risk she would commit suicide.

    Supported by her family

    Today the High Court heard that Miss D is in care following an incident where her mother punched her in the stomach.

    Her mother is an alcoholic, although she is off drink and sober at the moment.  

    In documents given to the court, Miss D said she was extremely distressed by the news she received last week that her baby would not survive.

    The girl said she decided to have an abortion because of the physical and mental trauma the pregnancy would cause.   

    She said she was supported by her mother and her boyfriend's mother and both families would come up with funds to help her secure the termination.

    She said it had been made abundantly clear to her that unless she was considered a suicide risk she would not be given permission by the HSE to travel for the abortion.

    Miss D said she was not suicidal.

    She said she believed she would be arrested if tried to leave the state. 

    The teenager added it seemed inhumane to expect her to carry a baby to term in circumstances where it had been condemned to death once born.

    She said the life of the baby was not in question.  

    The diagnosis of anencephaly and the life expectancy of the baby is not disputed by the HSE.

    She said she was shocked by the extent to which the HSE had chosen to ignore her wishes, and to treat her as if she had no right to personal autonomy.

    Miss D said the situation was wholly unacceptable and she could not believe that she was prevented from exercising rights that any other 17-year-old in the State would have to travel for a termination simply because she was in the care of the HSE.

    A full hearing of the case will take place on Thursday.

    Right to travel 'absolute'

    Meanwhile the CEO of the children's charity, Barnardos has spoken about the controversial case.

    Speaking in Clonmel, Fergus Finlay said a referendum was passed in 1992, which gives every citizen in Ireland an automatic and unqualified right to travel to another jurisdiction for procedures that are legal abroad. 

    He thinks that right is absolute.

    Mr Finlay described it as a terribly tragic case, a terrible tragedy for the young woman.

    Tweet
    • Most Popular
    • Top Stories
    • 1 Diesel laundering operation found in Dublin
    • 2 Wallace to make complaint over Shatter comments
    • 3 EU to ban olive oil jugs in restaurants from 2014
    • 4 'People of interest' in Madeleine McCann case
    • 5 Medical Council seeks changes to abortion law
    • 6 Woman tells gardaí she drove over body in Co Clare
    • 7 13 treated following Roscommon water pollution
    • 8 Man held in Waterford sexual abuse investigation
    • 1 Taoiseach '100%' behind Justice Minister
    • 2 Doubts raised over reaching savings target in 2013
    • 3 Murder inquiry launched after Tallaght body find
    • 4 Cyclist killed in Co Kildare road crash
    • 5 Kenny lays wreath at Boston bombings memorial
    • 6 Single winner for US $590.5m lottery jackpot
    • 7 September sittings for backlogged courts
    • 8 Briton questioned in France over children's deaths

    Search RTÉ News

      Search

      Highlights  

      • World Report

        Questions remain in Bangladesh after more than 1,000 people were killed when a building housing garment factories collapsed

      • The Week In Pictures

        Some of the most striking images from around the world this week

      • Prime Time

        Minister for Justice Alan Shatter and independent TD Mick Wallace discuss the penalty points controversy

       

      Live Player

      • watch live

        The Week in Politics

      • Next
      • 09:00 - 11:05

        Morning Edition

      • 13:00 - 13:25

        RTÉ News: One O'Clock and Weather

      • Later
      • 13:00 - 13:45

        RTÉ Radio - News at One (Studio Webcam)

      • 16:25 - 16:35

        news2day

      View complete live schedule »

      Also In The News  

      • Great Danes

        Emmelie de Forest won the Eurovision Song Content for Denmark with the song Only Teardrops

      • Morning Ireland News Quiz

        Cruz, Paris, Romeo: which one is not a child of Beckham's?

      • Barbie Blues

        Women's rights protesters have disrupted the opening of a giant pink doll's house in Berlin

       

      In Focus  

      • Blood Pressure Alert

        High blood pressure is a silent risk factor for stroke and heart attack and should not go unchecked

      • House of Horrors

        Dr Kermit Gosnell's House of Horrors was well-known to the local community of West Philadelphia, blogs Richard Downes

      • Banking Union

        Read a blog from Europe Editor Tony Connelly on depositors and the painful road to a banking union

       

      Documentary on One  

      • Songs My Mother Taught Me

        A 'documentary novel' by Chris Brookes about war brides - women who married allied servicemen during World War II

      • Over There - Green Cab

        A London taxi tour around the stories of the Irish in London, including the more recently-arrived

      • Dudley Kane: Darach Ó Cathain is here in Leeds

        In 1963, Sean nós singer Darach Ó Cathain emigrated to Leeds with his family. This radio documentary follows their journey

       
      • Prime Time

        Prime Time

        In-depth analysis of current issues and topical reports with Miriam O'Callaghan, Pat Kenny and Claire Byrne. Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays on RTÉ One

      • RTÉ News on Twitter

        RTÉ News on Twitter

        Get the latest news updates on Twitter by following @rtenews

      • Euro Blog

        Euro Blog

        Tony Connelly and Paul Cunningham analyse the politics of Brussels and issues from across Europe

      • US Blog

        US Blog

        The latest stories from America from Washington Correspondent Richard Downes

      Explore RTÉ

    • News
    • Sport
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Radio
    • Television
    • RTÉ Player
    • RTÉ Radio Player
    • Weather
    • Life & Style
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Homes
    • Motors
    • Travel
    • TRTÉ
    • RTÉjr
    • Orchestras
    • RTÉ Archives
    • RTÉ Guide
    • Shop
    • m.rte.ie
    • RTÉ Aertel
    • Classifieds
    • Dating
    • Jobs
    • Lotto
    • RTÉ Apps
    • RTÉ Live
    • RTÉ YouTube
    • Email alerts
    • RTÉ Digital Blog
    • RTÉ is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
      Images courtesy of Inpho.ie and Getty Images

      RTÉ

      RTÉ.ie is the website of Raidió Teilifís Éireann, Ireland's National Public Service Broadcaster.

      Information
      Feedback
      Complaints

    • About RTÉ
    • Contact
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Data Protection Policy
    • Privacy Statement
    • Licence Fee
    • Careers
    • Annual Report
    • Advertise with RTÉ
    • RTÉ NL
    • SAORVIEW
    • © RTÉ 2012-RTÉ Commercial Enterprises Ltd, Registration No: 155076, Donnybrook, Dublin 4, Ireland.

       
      • Visit our commercial partners
      • myhome.ie
      • buyandsell.ie
      • anotherfriend.ie
      • irishjobs.ie
      • carzone.ie