The Frontline Blog

Tonight on The Frontline

Monday, 01 Feb 2010
David Nally
Editor

There are few subjects that illicit more emotion from the public than attacks on the elderly in their own homes. Right now a new bill to clarify the rights of people to fight back when their home is invaded is being debated in the Oireachtas, it is likely to become law soon.

There's a large measure of consensus that anyone who is faced with an attacker in their home does have a right to attack back and that there shouldn't be an onus on the householder to first attempt to retreat before resorting to attack.

There is still plenty of argument, however, about how much force should be acceptable and in what circumstances. Most of all, though, campaigners on the issue often argue that the right to fight back is largely useless to an elderly person whose home is attacked in the middle of the night. How many old age pensioners will be capable of producing a weapon and killing or seriously injuring a young man in those circumstances?

Far more useful, campaigners say, would be strong measures to prevent elderly people's homes being invaded in the first place. This week Justice Minister Dermot Ahern signalled his sympathy for that position with calls for mandatory sentencing for attacks on the elderly and said he had initiated a review of the option by the Law Reform Commission.

On The Frontline tonight we'll have arguments for and against the enhanced right to fight back against attacks in your own home and on the hot issue of mandatory sentencing.

Also we'll be joined the new President of the Irish Farmers Association John Bryan who has come out fighting against the power of the big retailers who, he says, are paying rip-off prices to farmers for their produce. At the same time, there are renewed campaigns, reminiscent of the 1980s, for us to "buy Irish" when we do our food shopping.

What do you think? As a country that exports the vast majority of its food produce should we be calling on consumers to buy Irish? Or should Irish food take its chances in the marketplace with imported food which may be cheaper? Can we trust the quality of imported food?

Let us know your view on both of these subjects by emailiing thefrontline@rte.ie or by posting your comments on this blog.

Enjoy the programme.



Comments:

Hi i am a 33 year old gay woman living with my partner on new years day morning at 3.45am a man came to my door and assulted me, which his friend ripped down 2 cctv from my house. I chased them away with a craving knife. I called the gardai 6 times they won't come out because of the really bad snow. I have since made a statement. I heard no more about until today when i contacted the gardai who advised me to drop the charges. So i have a appointment with my solictor this wednesday. So what if they had killed me?

Posted by anonymous on February 01, 2010 at 10:54 PM GMT #

The scum who break into people`s houses should have no rights whatsoever. If more people used deadly force to put a couple of these scumbags in the ground, where they belong, then there would be no need for stiffer sentences and would save a lot of time and money. At the very least they should receive 14 years with no possibility of parole. People last year were going to jail for debt, yet we are here debating the rights of scumbags. What a world we live in! Robert Richard.

Posted by Rob Richard on February 01, 2010 at 11:03 PM GMT #

Hi Pat, I feel that the issue of criminals having multible offences is an absolute joke in reference to justice in this Country. If a criminal has more than 2 offences for a crime then the severity of the charge and subsequent punishment must increase dramatically. Also in the area of time off for good behaviour must be revisited with time added for bad behaviour as a distinct difference.

Posted by Sean McCormack on February 01, 2010 at 11:12 PM GMT #

Could I ask why the presenter of tonight's show is more intent on thrusting his own prejudices on the topic down our throats rather than letting the excellent and interesting persons selected to appear on the show by the Editor. Why bother having experienced persons on the show, all of whom have informed contributions to offer on this complicated debate. Why not just leave it to Pat and his one-sided view of everything. Please Editor/Producer keep him in line!

Posted by John Clarke on February 01, 2010 at 11:20 PM GMT #

Cross-border shopping: My experience is that it is the middle-class (not too strapped) families that are going North and are buying non-essentials such as alcohol & electrical goods. Also, disappointed at the amount of "irish" goods that actually are produced in UK e.g. Wexford Creamery Cheese. We try to buy Irish where we can but concerns about labeling of products, especially dairy and meats, is giving cause for concern.

Posted by Declan Buckley on February 01, 2010 at 11:22 PM GMT #

I think anyone who breaks into another persons house should be jailed and the key thrown away. Damn reform its not a holiday camp they are supposed to be punished. I'm saying this after being robbed 5 times. If I had a gun well.....

Posted by Mary Cumiskey on February 01, 2010 at 11:24 PM GMT #

What is eddie hobbs on about? as soon as all the government are shown the door the better for the country.kevin creaven galway

Posted by kevin creaven on February 01, 2010 at 11:35 PM GMT #

There are those who would believe that Eddie Hobbs should be on the other side of bars so I'd be sceptical of any of his advice (especially given his previous advice on Brandon Investments) and his own property investments!!!

Posted by Patrick Kenny on February 01, 2010 at 11:36 PM GMT #

Pat was totally biased. Obviously, nobody wants to see elderly people being attacked, or to have a burglar in the house. Personally, I wouldn't be stopping to consider the legal implications if there were a burglar in my house, I would be too busy dealing with the situation. I don't believe these laws would stop the burglars coming. It is a failing of society that babies grow up to do such things. Attack the root of the problems. Deprivation and poverty. It costs 1/4 million to house a prisoner for a year. Surely this money could be spent in a more beneficial way for society.

Posted by Gordon on February 01, 2010 at 11:36 PM GMT #

Why can't I go North to shop? The Government has no problem taking tenders from the North. Half the roads built in the last 5yrs have been done by Northern firms. I'm sick of their double standards. I'm also not going to prop up the people that have been ripping us off for the last 10yrs with higher and higher prices. Don't pull the traitors string with us. We shop where we can get the best value for the money we have and nobody will make us feel guilty for it. We've had Europe and a single economy talk for the last 30yrs. Well, this is what it's about and when we truly have freedom of movement, goods and services, then the Irish government will know what's sticking to it. Barry.

Posted by Barry Colgan on February 01, 2010 at 11:37 PM GMT #

In rural areas, remote from Garda presence, or even neighbours, a right to fight back is essential. Regardless of what the law says, people who live close to an hour away from the nearest barracks are compelled to take matters into their own hands. We as a society should not punish them for doing so. If we are unable to provide an effective police protection to every home in ireland, then we must be mad to be requiring homeowners to flee their home and leave it to the burglars.

Posted by Tommy Tighe on February 03, 2010 at 03:34 PM GMT #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.
Twitter Facebook
subscribe
« January 2012
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
      
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
     
Today