Entertainment
Television Blog

The X Factor - Final Weekend

Joe is a worthy winner.Finally, we have a winner and it's little Joe - a very deserving victor. Yes, I'm still Team Olly but I think it might be a blessing in disguise that he didn't win the show.

All these highs and lows…
It was a weekend of ups and downs for The X Factor finalists, with slippy shoes, frosty celebs and a bit of waffle from the judges! And while it was entertaining throughout, the final didn't seem to have the drama and excitement of last year. Maybe it was due to the fact that there was no Beyoncé-style duet or maybe it was because it seemed that the winner had already been decided before the show kicked off.

The much-anticipated duets
Stacey was great with Michael BubléFor me Stacey stole the show with her duet with Michael Bublé. It wasn't the song that they chose, nor just how they sang it, it was more about the fact that they seemed to have great chemistry. Michael Bublé really made the effort to make her feel comfortable, to have fun with her and to let her have her moment. The same cannot be said of Robbie Williams and George Michael.

For me, although I've always liked him, I thought Robbie totally messed up his duet with Olly. He forgot the words, seemed more starstruck than the contestant that he was there to help and then proceeded to start chants before even finishing the song properly. It seemed messy and left you really feeling for poor Olly. I was watching it almost screaming at the telly: "Pull yourself together man".

Not overly impressed with George Michael's effort!And then to George Michael, well he was just too cool to be there, wasn't he?! I felt so sorry for Joe trying to interact with him when it seemed like George Michael was intent on ignoring him for most of the performance and then when he came out with that classic line about how the poor contestants must have been quaking about meeting people like I him… well, enough said. Hate to break it to you George but they've met Whitney, I'm sure they were fine about bumping into you in the corridor. Joe was a pro for this duet though. He really pulled it off so all credit to him there.

That single
The moment we'd all been waiting for!Joe will do well with The Climb. I'm glad that it was his first single and, to be honest, I totally breathed a sigh of relief when Dermot called out his name as the winner. The song was clearly chosen with him in mind and he makes it his own. I actually really liked Miley Cyrus' version of the song but it's not a track that suits everyone's style or voice. So you'd have to wonder if this business of selecting a 'one-song-fits-all' winning track is getting a little old. OK, so this has never happened on The X Factor before, but what if the final three were a rapper, a hip-hop artist and an opera singer? Would you expect all three of them to be able to release the same track if they won? It would be silly. And it's also silly to presume that every singer, although asked to be versatile during the competition, can carry off the same style as a recording artist.

Olly pulled out all the stops... but it wasn't enough.I voted for Olly all weekend. I think he was the most entertaining contestant in the show this year. He's got a natural flare and energy that you just can't teach performers. But I stopped voting when I heard his version of The Climb. It wasn't that he didn't sing it well. In fact, he gave it his all. But it was clear that he didn't think much of the song (no matter how much the judges tried to convince us that he loved it!). And so, from that point on, I was hoping that he wouldn't actually win the show. I'd much prefer for him to be able to start his career with a song that he actually likes and that shows off his merits as an artist. I'm convinced that we haven't seen the last of Olly Murs. As for Joe, I'm sure he'll do well for himself too, maybe taking on a 'High School Musical'-style project or in the West End.

Shake Things Up
Paul McCartney was a true pro.There were lots of little changes to The X Factor this year and I'm kind of hoping that the proposed changes (the ones mentioned in the tabloids!) go ahead for next year. I think that it would be a good idea for the judges to take an act from each category. And I'd like to see a celebrity judge on the panel each week, just to mix things up, and there would probably be celebrities queuing up for their chance to get involved judging by the amount of them who rave about the show at the minute and sign up for masterclasses. Speaking of masters of their art, how cool was Paul McCartney jamming with the contestants?

Back again!He came across as very down to earth and happy to be there – loved Simon's little joke with him too… staying with Simon, what's with him dissing very popular Journey songs every week?! What planet does he live on?... And finally, before this turns into the longest blog ever, I have to say I loved, loved, loved the performance by Alexandra Burke and JLS. Fair play to them all for having a bit of fun for the occasion.

Well, that's it for another year. The series always seems to go by far too quickly. What will we do on Saturday nights from now on?! All that's left now is for me to have my 'Seacrest Out' moment… except I don't think I'm quite cool enough to pull that off… so it's a 'thanks for reading people' instead!

Linda McGee

Check out our 'X Factor Final' photo gallery here.


 


Comments:

I hope Joe doesn't disapear now just like Leon....

Posted by Sarah on December 14, 2009 at 11:24 AM GMT #

Definately think Olly should have won, but they way things went over the weekend with his guest singer bad choice for Olly and the song that was selected for the winner he had no hope. Congrats to Joe a great little singer but I reckon we won't be seeing him for long in the pop world but he will definately be brill for the West End

Posted by Siobhan Murphy Sutton on December 14, 2009 at 11:45 AM GMT #

I like Joe, he's very cute but it is disgraceful that the song was chosen for him and it clearly was. I was rooting for Olly but I have to agree with you Linda, better to start of as he means to go on! This year was a big disappointment for me overall, really from the start of the the live shows. None of the contestants really appealed to me, like past years (last year and Leona's year!) and therefore I didn't really care who won and ended up not watching alot of it at all. I was so excited seeing JLS & Alex together, I actually felt really emotional as I really liked both acts last year and I'm delighted that they've done so well. Love Leona too! Let's hope next year will provide us with more exciting acts than this year!

Posted by Amy on December 14, 2009 at 11:58 AM GMT #

Joe was the true winner -picked him from the start and has nobody every picked up on how much he looks like donny osmond when he was younger I think he will go far.

Posted by Lorraine Newman on December 14, 2009 at 11:58 AM GMT #

I was really disappointed Olly didnt win as he was such a great entertainer. I think Joe is a great singer but as in a pop star I don't see it, I couldnt see him preforming in the O2 getting the crowd going as in the way Olly would. I have a horrible feeling that this time next year it will be the case of another Leon.. but hope Olly will have the same success of JLS. Still team Olly... and what was cheryl wearing

Posted by ashling on December 14, 2009 at 12:01 PM GMT #

I think Joe really dereved the win!! He was the best singer from the start and he will have a great career! The best part is that there is nobody to compare him with! i liked Olly too, and I believe we have not seen the last of him!!

Posted by Sean on December 14, 2009 at 01:03 PM GMT #

I was for Olly to win all the way through until I heard the winning song. I hope now he gets to record the album that he would be proud to put his name to and not the one that will line Simon Cowells pockets. As for Joe, lets face it is was all his gran's friends from bingo that were voting for him. I don't know what all the hype was about him - an absolute one trick pony. Really bored of him. I also don't think it has ever been more obvious in any other serious that the whole show is a fix, did anybody notice last night that when Olly was singing Joe's number was the first in line?

Posted by Nicola on December 14, 2009 at 01:14 PM GMT #

hi, I think Joe was Brillant all trough the competition. He sang perfect every night. I would go to see him in concert,He is only 18, by the time he is Ollys age he will have all the moves and a great voice to go with them.Just class Joe.

Posted by annmarie on December 14, 2009 at 02:34 PM GMT #

The final really showed the X Factor up for the fix that it is. Simon never seemed to be behind Olly at all. He wanted Joe to win and made that very clear. The whole show was geared for Joe to win. I think it's madness because there's no doubt about it Joe will have one album and then we'll see him on I'm a Celebrity in a few years.... Olly may have been a much better winner. The show as a whole was very lacklustre this year. I was not bothered about any of the contestants really and only watched the last 15 minutes last need to see who won. I think they should get rid of the categories completely. Too many good singers are left out because the categories are full. This year was a prime example. The groups were terrible and there were 3 better acts between the other categories that should have been there instead. A big shake up is needed with the show because there are a lot of problems there in my opinion. Danni Minogue for the axe please in favour of someone who actually knows something about the music business :)

Posted by Aaron on December 14, 2009 at 02:35 PM GMT #

Delighted Joe won - I love his voice. He has a lot more to give and will be a very successful recording artist. Joe is seven years younger than Olly - he hasn't had Olly's life experiences yet and I can only see him grow in confidence.

Posted by m on December 14, 2009 at 02:42 PM GMT #

i just dont understand how people just can't accept that Joe was a better singer!!! He deserved it more! I do think Olly was good but just not as good as Joe! And then talking about how Joes number was on the screen first??!!!!

Posted by Sean on December 14, 2009 at 02:46 PM GMT #

Who's Leon?

Posted by Brendan Cole on December 14, 2009 at 02:55 PM GMT #

I think the best singer won. Although Olly is considered by many to be entertaining, and to give him his due he can hold a note, it is obvious that he does depend on a good stage production to really get into things. His weakest performance was when it was just him and a microphone. As for the duet with Robbie Williams, it really made me think I had stumbled into a wedding at the end of a long night and caught the groom and best man in the middle some sort of drunken performance. What were they all thinking? I really liked Stacey and Buble, it was great and I also enjoyed Joe & George, it proved that Joe could hold his own with one of the greatest singers (although George clearly is living in a bit of a twilight zone!). Thank goodness he didn't ruin the performance for Joe like Robbie did. Joe was note perfect and is very cute, although I've said all along that he is more suited to the West End, I do hope that he is able to carve out a successful pop career. Olly on the other hand, I wish him well, but I hope he does the 'wiggly-worm' off into pop oblivion! Overall it was a great X-Factor weekend with something for all the family music-wise. Well done Linda on your great blogs, I've enjoyed reading them and disagreeing with you on lots of points. Congrats!

Posted by Fee on December 14, 2009 at 03:00 PM GMT #

Really disappointed olly didnt win, the climb wasnt the song for him at all. He struggled with it, i felt bad 4 him. That song was picked with joe/danyl/stacey in mind, not poor olly. But i kinda agree with u Linda, i think maybe it was a blessin in disguise that he didnt win, he can go on from him here and become the kind of artist he really wants to be singin songs that suit him. You could tell on sun nite that he didnt feel comfortable singin the climb so im sure a consolation for him when he didnt win as to think well at least he never has 2 sing that again. Let joe off to the west end.....olly is the real pop star

Posted by Claire on December 14, 2009 at 03:01 PM GMT #

I agree with you annmarie, joe has plenty of time to learn the tricks, he has a perfect start in that he has the most amazing voice. when he hit the key notes he brings a tear to my eye, he's that good. And anyway, most acts need dance and lights and tricks to compensate, I'd go to listen to that boy just singing, no frills needed. Delighted he won! I will admit that the song suited him better but then if Olly had stronger vocals he'd have had a better shot, simple as that!

Posted by N on December 14, 2009 at 03:16 PM GMT #

Olly was robbed..as good as what Joe was...Olly had the whole package-the voice in the range of songs he could sing, looks, personsality, the moves... All Joe done was belt out ballads week after week getting abit boring after a while....Think we are gonna see more of Mr Mur's in 2010 than we do of Joe McElderberry or whatever he's called lol!!!! OLLY OLLY OLLY OI OI OI!!!!

Posted by Emma on December 14, 2009 at 03:20 PM GMT #

I wanted Olly to win. Joe bugs the living daylights out of me! He's got a great voice in fairness to him, but zero stage presence. He's boring and his audience is mainly older people, and theatre go-ers. Olly was the all round entertainer and in my eyes will emerge as the true winner. He'll go on to have a longer lasting chart career than the winner himself.

Posted by Amy H on December 14, 2009 at 03:20 PM GMT #

Glad the show is over. The winning song definitely suited Joe more and you could clearly see that Olly wasn't happy with it. Has anyone seen the voting percentages for the whole series? In the week Jedward were eliminated they didn't receive the lowest number of votes, Olly did. The whole 'X Factor' thing has lost its spark and should be replaced IMO.

Posted by Sarah on December 14, 2009 at 03:46 PM GMT #

Thank god Olly didn't win, cause that terrible "winners song" would have killed any credible career he could have hoped for. song was for joe and joe only!!! so best of luck to joe cause he will need it! Olly does not need the show now and i hope himself stacey and danyl have a long and fantastic career ahead of them. thanks for the blog linda, even if we did diagree on danyl!!

Posted by val on December 14, 2009 at 03:53 PM GMT #

Thought it really unfair that some papers in the UK blamed Michael Buble's performance with Stacey as the reason why she did nt make it to the final two... He is such a good singer and entertainer and you could tell that the two of them had fun singing together. At the end of the day the best singer won. Thanks to X factor and Friday nights Late late I've become a big Buble fan - very cool guy...

Posted by Sparky on December 14, 2009 at 05:32 PM GMT #

Sean, with the greatest of respect to you, its not all about being a great singer. Look at some of the highest achievers in the music industry, Kylie, Madonna, Robbie, not great singers but can give the public what they want, a good performance, and songs that they can sing along too and a paragraph every now and then in a gossip column. Joe is going to irritate everybody with his far too sweet to be true personality.

Posted by Nicola on December 14, 2009 at 06:30 PM GMT #

I'm so upset Olly didnt win :( but I guess sometimes its better to come second then to win the competition because you work harder.For example G4,Rhydian and JLS all have great careers and they all came 2nd

Posted by Ruth prendergast on December 14, 2009 at 08:59 PM GMT #

Killing in the Name for No.1!!!! X Factor is ruining the music industry. Be a part of the revolution!!!!!

Posted by John on December 15, 2009 at 12:07 AM GMT #

Have to say that this years show was the best ever - totally hooked ! And by the time we got to the final 3, I didn't care who won. I mean for the 1st time ever, I wasn't shouting or voting for a winner because I thought they were all very good, very pally and great personalities.......... Unlike in other years.

Posted by kenno on December 15, 2009 at 07:48 AM GMT #

Joe was great, from start to finish. No moaning,no ranting just note perfect singing for 10 weeks. I missed Jedward - they were entertainment! Olly was being boxed as the next Robbie Wiliiams - do we need another one? Also I felt sorry for Olly when they said on Xtra Factor that Robbie was texting/phoning him all week & spent the day with him - he would have been much better without that hassle. Also Sinitta said that it took Simon until this week to get over loosing Danyl. He had his eggs in one basket - its great how public just won't deliver what Simon wants. STACY & BUBLE WAS A GREAT PERFORMANCE.

Posted by Caroline on December 15, 2009 at 09:14 AM GMT #

Thank God its over for another year. Its about time we put an end to the Karaoke Factor, none of the contestants are going to last longer then Christmas, they'll all be back to their sob stories within few weeks, popping up every now and again in "I'm a Nobody let me on Televison". There is real talent out there not getting a chance because they don't fit into the Karaoke Factor view of things. I'll be doing my bit by buying Killing in the Name of

Posted by Colin on December 15, 2009 at 10:46 AM GMT #

Joe was brillant from day 1 and definitely deserved to win, I can't wait to buy his album whenever it comes out. Olly was good and is an absolutely great show man I doubt we have heard the last of him either. I would also hope that we haven't heard the last of Stacey.

Posted by Mary on December 15, 2009 at 12:11 PM GMT #

I thought Stacey performed the best she ever had on Saturday night I had goose bumps when she sang and to me that is a sign of a good singer, I was like that when Alex sang with Beyonce last year. Olly was very entertaining pity Robbie messed up talk about a bromance. joe was brill too. I really didn't care come Sunday who won, maybe that was because I had my Xmas party on Friday night. Alex and JLS were brill also. Agree with Aaron Danni for the chop, and maybe a guest judge every week or even just have a theme don't have the singer/group mentoring then they are the guest judge contestants might just perform out of there skins. thank god I still have one more week with strictly going to miss Xfactor..Only way to end this is Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year

Posted by t on December 15, 2009 at 03:56 PM GMT #

Delighted for Joe. He was the better of the two. I really thought Stacey should have been in the final. She was absolutely amazing on Saturday night. Her performance with Mr. Buble was easily the best of the duets. They had real chemistry and seemed to have lots of fun not like the others. I really hope she gets a record deal, she makes singing seem to effortless! I would definitely buy her album. I was never a fan of Ollie. Best of luck to Joe. Danni is the best judge, don't understand why people don't like her. She is the fairest of the four of them.

Posted by Paul on December 15, 2009 at 09:34 PM GMT #

was disappointed that stacey didnt make it to the final her performances where brill and would to have loved to have her take on the climb . So happy joe won he was brilliant throughout the whole series the song was meant for joe nd stacey rather than olly :)

Posted by karen on December 15, 2009 at 10:29 PM GMT #

Have to agree with Paul Dannii is the best judge. She is the only judge to give the singers constructive criticism instead of the sort of rubbish that Cheryl comes out with i.e You smashed it or something equally meaningless. As for refering to a number of times as Joe and Olly being in the bottom 2, i'm sorry Luv but i'll think you'll find that was the top 2. She really bugs me, and the fact the so many people think she's so amazing really makes me despair.

Posted by JB on December 16, 2009 at 09:27 AM GMT #

Just like the majority of the previous posters Olly was my favourite. In hindsight the Robbie duet might have cost him the win, they should have done a song more suited to being a duet. Yes the name recognition of Robbie will have got him votes but if it was a good performance he could have snatched victory. Hopefully Olly will sign a deal and he'll be well looked after. He's the real star of this series for me.

Posted by Ollie on December 16, 2009 at 10:44 AM GMT #

I am very happy that this show is finally over, it has been one of the most over hyped TV shows ever. The contestants are boring and just like the singer from AH HEM 'One True Voice' we probably wont hear of them ever again!! One idea, why cant their Partner in the Duet (Famous talented musicians), help the contestants write a song and then perform it as their final song and be judged on that, maybe it will show if they have what it takes to be in the business i.e. Will Young, thats talent. Bring back Britains got talent, much more entertaining..

Posted by Song Writer on December 16, 2009 at 10:55 AM GMT #

Rage Against the Machine for Number 1 !!!!!!

Posted by sexitoni on December 16, 2009 at 02:02 PM GMT #

@ Song Writer are you failing to see your irony in pointing out Will Young as talented (i'm not disagreeing, he is) whilst complaining that most of the competitors will never be heard of again...are you aware that Will Young was found by Simon Cowell on one of these shows you detest so much? This rage against the machine campaign is just cringeworthy stuff also - are people aware that music has been manufactured for years - the monkees, the 80's acts of stock, aiken, waterman - there will always be music you like & music you don't like - the christmas number 1 hasn't been a big deal since top of the pops stopped running on a friday night, with downloads now taking up a large portion of what's listened to, does the christmas number really matter to anyone?

Posted by cath on December 17, 2009 at 09:43 AM GMT #

The final was pretty poor overall, it was dragged out and boring. Sad Olly was let down by Robbie, is it just me or does Robbie always have a "deer in headlights" look? Joe won but he doesnt have what it takes to succeed in the charts and needs an image change. Olly gave the best performances over the weekend, fair enough he wasnt vocally as strong, but he gave it his all. Rage Against The Machine for Number 1 :)

Posted by Paul M on December 17, 2009 at 02:24 PM GMT #

@cath what is cringeworthy is Simon Cowell and Cheryl Cole complaining about the people choosing to buy Rage Against The Machine. There seems to be an attitude that if you win X Factor you also get to have a number 1 single as part of the prize, I don't thats one of the prizes!

Posted by Colin on December 18, 2009 at 10:17 AM GMT #

Hopefully Rage will bury this single and the X Factor machine will start to wind down. I really hate this show and all it stands for.

Posted by Paul on December 18, 2009 at 05:01 PM GMT #

The right person won.Olly is an entertainer but Joe has the voice

Posted by Emma on December 18, 2009 at 09:08 PM GMT #

Used to love RATM back in the day hard to imagine this song is almost 20 years old flip that makes me feel old!!! Well the you kay gave the X factor what it deserved and unfortunatley the Irish music buying public like lambs didnt give disposable music the heave ho.....yet

Posted by The Saint on December 21, 2009 at 11:46 AM GMT #

Just to respond to the Saint. The Irish Xmas Chart isn't decided until the 24th of December. So RATM having entered at No.2 in the irish charts this week was down to people here downloading the song too early. For downloads to count towards the Irish Xmas no. 1, they should be made after Dec 18th, as this is when the Irish campaign organised by Phantom FM amongst others was due to start. So rage could still be Xmas no. 1 in Ireland.

Posted by AB on December 21, 2009 at 12:50 PM GMT #

I thoght olly was better than joe loved the x factor this year got the single and all. i hope stacy and olly get together anyway happy x mas to u all out there.

Posted by audrey on December 21, 2009 at 03:38 PM GMT #

Post a Comment:
Comments are closed for this entry.

 

.